Hoosier Daddy? Butler Deserves More Credit Than Comparisons To Film
- Tuesday, March 30, 2010 2:17 PM
- Written By: Forrest Lee
“Hoosiers.”
I’ve heard more about the overrated film and read more brainless schemes about running the picket fence in the past week to last a lifetime. I realize far too many columnists and broadcasters want to cast the Butler basketball team with this weak storyline, but it’s so misguided and predictable. What’s next, a movie about a fighter named “Rocky,” who wins the heavyweight title?
Come on, people. Is it really that simple and convenient? Have you been watching the Tournament? The greatest March Madness spectacle ever is being reduced to “Hoosiers”?
Even Butler’s coach, the boyish-looking Brad Stevens, got caught up in the euphoria.
“Wouldn’t it be cool if they moved the Final Four to Hinkle (Fieldhouse),” Stevens said, referring to the Bulldogs’ home gym in Indianapolis, site of the film’s biggest moment. “I’d be all for that.”
Calm down, coach. You know as well as anyone, the shoe just doesn’t fit.
Butler has strung together 24 consecutive wins, the nation’s longest streak, and a 32-4 mark. That speaks volumes for any basketball team, whether it’s playing in the Big East, Big 12, ACC, Horizon or Sisters of the Poor conferences.
Still, the Bulldogs, despite knocking off the two top seeds in their region (Syracuse and Kansas State), don’t get the respect of the other three Final Four schools.
Instead, their run earns comparisons to a film focusing on the exploits of an all-white high school basketball team more than 50 years ago. It dredges up the shameful and frequently ignored history of Indiana basketball, a history that conveniently buries the story of Oscar Robertson and the Crispus Attucks High basketball team, which achieved far more than little old Hickory High (or Milan, which the film is based on). When they’re done hallucinating in the Hollywood hoopla of “Hoosiers,” some of those same writers and broadcasters should do themselves a favor and watch the DVD “Something To Cheer About.” Robertson and his teammates couldn't even get a parade celebrating their achievements, let alone a film touting them.
Butler isn’t just another Cinderella story. The fact is the Bulldogs are a slight favorite to beat Michigan State in Saturday’s semifinals in Indy.
And if you want to cast a more likely candidate than Butler for the “Hoosiers” role, the Spartans would be more fitting. But that storyline doesn’t fit well into the neat and tidy little box dug up with all this nonsense. Plus, it wouldn’t play well in East Lansing.
Butler has proven it’s one of the best basketball teams in the Tournament. Simple as that. It has a shot at winning the national title and we can only imagine the party and comparisons that would generate. The Bulldogs are talented, play good defense and shoot 3’s as well as anyone.
But spare us the dumbing-down themes like we just rode in on the turnip truck from Alaska with Sarah Palin. We understand the significance of the Butler story, but the “Hoosiers’ comparisons are a stretch at best. Plus, they insult the achievements of the Butler basketball program and the passionate college basketball fans that know better.
Read more of Forrest Lee at Blak4rest.com.



