QB Match-up Makes Super Bowl Too Close To Call
- Tuesday, January 24, 2012 4:22 PM
- Written By: Jim Reich
We left on Sunday for our trip to Sarasota. Two and a half days and 1,265 miles later we arrived at our destination ... or so said our lady friend in the Garmin GPS. We took a longer route this year, going west to Columbus, Ohio, and then heading south. This enabled us to make a little visit to Chattanooga, which enjoyed very much. It reminded us of Pittsburgh as it sits on a river (Tennessee) and mountains surround it.
Being in the car on Sunday I heard most of the Ravens-Patriot game on the radio. I kept expecting Tom Brady to pull away with some brilliant passing. But I have to think the Ravens' defense kept him pretty much in check. In the meantime, Joe Flacco was connecting on big plays. I got into the motel just as Flacco threw to Lee Evans in the end zone. Had Evans held on to the ball, it would have put the Ravens up by four points and probably out of reach of Brady to get a TD to pull it out. But Evans allowed a second stringer to knock the ball out of his hands. Wow, what a bonehead play by Evans!
Then the Ravens had just enough time for Billy Cundiff to kick a field goal that would have sent the game into overtime. It was a chip shot. Cundiff pulled it to the right. Game over. It reminded me of Adam Vinatieri missing one for the Colts against the Steelers a few years ago. This enabled the Steelers to go on and eventually win the Super Bowl. It's great when it happens FOR your team. It's sickening when it happens AGAINST your team.
I saw parts of the Giants-Niners game. This one came down to a Niner fumbling a kickoff and the Giants kicking a field goal to win it. What a close game! In fact both of them were. Either team could have won. Eli Manning was something. He took more thumpings than Ben Roethlisberger does in an average game. But he kept coming back, extending plays, and completing clutch passes. Tremendous effort.
Baltimore fans, I completely understand your agony. I've been there. Giants fans, I totally comprehend your joy. I've been there.
So, now we have Brady against E. Manning. That's too close to call.
I have been listening to NFL radio in the car. The biggest question of the day, besides who will win the Super Bowl and who will coach Oakland, Miami and Tampa Bay, is what the Colts should do about P. Manning and the $28 million he will get this year if they keep him. $28 million! How can they afford that when he's 100 percent OK? And how can they justify paying him that when his future is cloudy, to say the least? I know he's a star, an icon, but football careers end, and think Peyton is through.
I am now thinking that the Steelers have a lot of decisions to make before long. One is whom to hire as offensive coordinator. Among other things, this guy has to get along with Ben. Bruce Arians did. But apparently the brass wasn't satisfied with his play calling and overall coaching. They also have to decide which of the old guard to retain (James Farrior, Casey Hampton, Chris Hoke, Hines Ward, etc.) and which to let go. Finally, they have to make draft decisions. One positive thing about not going to the Super Bowl is that they have an extra three or four weeks to plan. I think they need this extra time to get their heads on straight. It could also be a blessing to give the players some additional time off to heal and rest.




There were some great games over the weekend. I didn't see the Saints-49erss game as I was at a gathering. But throughout dinner, guys were checking their iPhones for scores. In that game the scoring was going back and forth almost by the minute. When the Saints took their first lead of the game at 24-23 with 4:01 left in the fourth quarter, I thought Drew Brees would cap it. But it didn't happen.
I was prepared to write the epitaph of the 2011 Steeler season. But I had it slotted for next Monday. I thought the Steelers would be able to squeak by Denver and reach their Waterloo in Foxborough. But something happened on the way ...
There were three positives in this game.
Despite the special appliance that we wore and taking all the chemicals known to mankind to dull the pain, he hobbled around. He passed for more than 300 yards, while suffering three interceptions and a fumble. He also seemed to start every drive deep in his own territory. So, he did his best, but it fell short. Should he have played? That's a question that a mere fan cannot answer. He did. He wasn't at his best. That's NFL football.
The win over the Bengals actually started out iffy for the Steelers. After the opening kickoff they went three and out. The Bengals then ran right through them, but sputtered on about the 15-yard line. They lined up for a field goal and made it. But it was negated by a penalty. On the second attempt from five yards deeper, Cam Heyward got a mitt up and blocked the kick. The Steelers recovered and the rout was on.
Cassel, a legitimate NFL QB, goes down. You look down your list of backups and what what do you see? Tyler Palko (pictured). Palko has all the tools. He was a better-than-average QB at Pitt (here's that Western PA connection again), but he's started but one NFL game. You sign Kyle Orton on Wednesday. But you can't play him because he doesn't know the system, the personnel. So, it's Palko or nothing. Boy, Crennel does his job. The Steelers are having a murderous time scoring. But Palko turns the ball over three times in the first half, and then once more when the Chiefs are driving to win the game with about 40 seconds on the clock in the fourth quarter. Game over.
Speaking of other games, Baltimore shredded the Cincinnati rookie QB, Dalton. They really never gave him a chance to get off his quick passes. When he did, it seemed that his receivers had to make sensational catches on balls that were thrown low, wide, you get the picture. So, in a mere two weeks, the luster is off the Bengals. They are a good team on the rise, but they are not quite ready for prime time. In the meantime, the Ravens proved themselves to be the real deal and could easily get to the Super Bowl. Even without Ray Lewis, who seems to be suffering an injury that could lead to his retirement, the Ravens defense is awesome. By the way, I say that Lewis' injury could lead to the end of his long career. It's a toe problem. But I've seen it time and again ... an older player has what looks like a minor injury. But older guys can't recover as quickly and these things seem to hang on and nag until it becomes apparent that while he has slowed down considerably over the past five years, this could just do it. We'll see.
The Steelers did something Sunday that they haven't been able to do this season. They made two key interceptions. The last one was during a final drive by the Bengals who were trying to tie the game with time ticking off the clock. The goat of the Ravens game, William Gay, who allowed Torrey Smith to catch the winning TD with 8 seconds left a week ago, intercepted Andy Dalton's pass by jumping the route to preserve the Steeler win. Earlier, Gay tipped a tipped a pass to Lawrence Timmons for another interception.
The Steelers' defense couldn't get off the field. Time after time they were able to limit the Ravens on first and second down, but they couldn't stop Flacco from making the crucial third down play that kept drives alive all night long. The Steelers almost never got near Flacco in time to hurry him or sack him. James Harrison played his heart out (and the Steelers did miss LaMarr Woodley), but it wasn't enough. So, the Ravens will carry the AFC North title into the playoffs, almost assuredly getting home field advantage throughout. They deserve it. Provided they can keep up the intensity that they showed in the two games against the Steelers it is hard to imagine any team in the AFC that can top them.
So, what happened? The Steelers coaching staff drew up a game plan that caught B/B with their hands in the cookie jar, a complete reversal of about seven or eight years. In case people weren't noticing, Roethlisberger changed his stripes a few games ago. With a beaten-up offensive line that allowed sack after sack, Ben began a three-step drop routine. Unlike the Ben of old who surveyed and surveyed and then made his living my eluding some on charging sackers and throwing on the run, Ben backpedaled and within about three seconds threw the ball. This was the plan that he and Bruce Arians drew up Sunday.
So, despite their awful showing to date, you know these guys were up for this home game. They had something to prove. But when it was all said and done, they didn't have the fan support a usual hometown team gets as the place was loaded with Terrible Towels, and they didn't have the personnel on the field to compete adequately with the Steelers. They were outplayed, period, and the Steelers emerged with a win over a team in obvious disarray.
But then the second half began and everything for the Steelers went backwards. They gained 55 yards in the second half. Trying to block a punt (which I thought he actually accomplished), Ryan Mundy ran into the kicker and gave the Jags new life.