Great, Not Greatest II -- Kobe Bryant
- Monday, October 25, 2010 4:55 PM
- Written By: Andy Wasif
Last week, we debunked the myth that Phil Jackson is “the greatest coach of all-time” as some erroneously refer to him. In Part II or our in-depth exposé, we take on one of the men who will remain tied to Jackson throughout history – Kobe Bryant, a.k.a “the Black Mamba.”
Now Bryant is another story and the media really, really want to anoint him "the greatest Laker of all-time." And Kobe wants it badly. As much as he says he doesn’t, you can see it in his eyes. And you can see it in Magic’s eyes when he says, “Remind me again who Kobe is.”
First of all, anyone saying this either didn’t watch Magic (or Jerry West or Kareem or Shaq) play or just doesn’t understand what they’re saying. They’re on the fringe, covering one end of the spectrum. We can eliminate them from the discussion. Están loco en la cabeza, as they say in LA. Then let’s eliminate those people that just don’t like Kobe because he’s an adulterer and an accused rapist. That’s immaterial in this argument.
I can even give him a mulligan for his John Starksian choke in Game 7. (If Kobe’s given the MVP, shouldn’t he have to share it with Ron Artest? Or how about Ray Allen for looking even more John Starksian?) Everyone’s allowed a bad game, though, in the biggest close-out of his life, he was more the problem than the solution. That never happened to Magic.
Kobe really looked out of sorts throughout the entire series. He has a tendency to get flustered and make a whole lot of bad decisions. Michael never seemed to sweat, even in his bad games.
One way that Kobe is like Mike, however, are with the “Kobe rules.” Michael had the “Jordan rules” and Kobe has them apparently tenfold. That’s one problem with the league is that they cater to the superstars. A travel isn’t a travel. Patrick Ewing never traveled, John Stockton or Larry Bird never clutched or grabbed, and Kobe never fouled out. (I used to think an elbow to the face was a foul until I watched Kobe play. Silly me.)
I have to hand it to the Lakers, though, as they really emulated the great Celtics and Pistons teams of the 80’s for never actually committing a foul. The begging and pleading they do after being called for one looks like they’re auditioning for a daytime soap ... or to play for a FIFA soccer team.
And considering the Lakers have been handed entire games by the refs (SEE: Great, Not Greatest, Part I), they are the team that should be complaining the least.
If you watched only the 2010 Finals, Kobe fouled out of at least two games. But there was no way any ref wanting to keep his job was going to whistle him for his sixth foul on any of those nights. ("I dint see nuttin'.")
If Paul Pierce drove the lane and Kobe literally took out a gun and shot him, the refs would’ve convened at midcourt and concluded that it was Celtics ball out of bounds ... or maybe a defensive three seconds.
The league and, more specifically, the officiating, were less blatantly bad during Magic’s era. And remember, Magic played only 12 years, winning virtually half the time and led his team. Kobe played second fiddle to one Shaq Man Du, a.k.a. (this season) “the Big Shamrock,” for nearly a decade.
The only thing upon which you could possibly base the argument that Kobe is as good as Magic is the number of rings Kobe has won. He has five and Magic has five. Okay, so does Derek Fisher. Does that mean Fish is as good as Magic too? Remember from last week’s post that Robert Horry has eight. Is he better than Magic?
Also, Kobe has been named the league Most Valuable Player only one time. He’s in that rarefied air of Allen Iverson (“the Answer”), David Robinson (“the Admiral”) and Charles Barkley (“the guy on TNT with an opinion on everything”).
As far as Lakers go, Magic has three MVP awards; Kareem has three on the Lakers alone (six overall); even Shaq has won the Maurice Podoloff trophy as many times as Kobe has. So Kobe’s the “best Laker of all-time?”
Look, the league has changed. Comparing the present to the past isn’t well-reasoned. Read a little bit about how the league used to be and you’ll come away very enlightened. It’ll be a chance to learn about when the league was on top of the world and not scraping for coverage with NFL team activities in the off-season.
Kobe may be great, and may be the “best closer in the game,” (perhaps because he’s frequently put in a position to launch ill-advised shots at the end of games, some which go in), but certainly not the best “of all-time,” in the history of his franchise, let alone the entire sport.
So let’s try to keep the logic in this discussion regardless of what the media and the “experts” are trying to spin. As we’ve already pointed out when speaking of Phil Jackson, it makes for better television to claim you’re watching the best of all-time. For this era, these icons are certainly and inarguably among the best, but let’s not go all loco en la cabeza here.
I'm Andy Wasif and I approved this blog post.



